
I Followed My Surgical Instruments. What I Discovered Changed How I Think About Surgery
Orthopedic Surgery • Attending Physician •
Published on 11/08/2026
After decades of performing orthopedic surgery, I found myself doing something I had never done before.
I followed my surgical instruments.
Not into another operating room, but into the sterile processing department.
The decision followed one of the most difficult experiences of my surgical career. A patient developed a devastating postoperative infection that ultimately required an amputation.
Surgical site infections are multifactorial. Patient characteristics, microbial factors, surgical conditions, and numerous other variables influence their development. I had no reason to believe sterile processing contributed to this complication. But the experience compelled me to look more deeply at the entire ecosystem surrounding surgical care.
For years, I had focused on refining surgical techniques, improving outcomes, introducing new technologies, and making the operating room more efficient. I had spent decades examining what happened during surgery, but how much attention had I given to everything surrounding it?
What might I be missing simply because I had become so accustomed to the way we do things?
So I followed my instruments.
What I discovered was an intricate world of surgical care that I had never fully appreciated. I watched instruments move through decontamination, cleaning, inspection, assembly, and sterilization. I watched dedicated professionals remove blood, bone, marrow, fat, and other organic material from increasingly complex surgical instruments.
It was meticulous, labor-intensive, technically demanding work, essential to every operation I performed but largely invisible to those of us on the other side of the operating room doors.
I began asking questions. Why was so much of the work of instrument cleaning concentrated after surgery? Could more be accomplished while instruments were still in the operating room? And could we accomplish that without creating even more work for our surgical teams?
One Surgical Ecosystem
As surgeons, we tend to measure efficiency through the lens of the operating room. We monitor operative times, room turnover, instrument availability, and surgical outcomes. We invest in robotics, navigation, advanced imaging, and technologies designed to improve precision and procedural consistency.
But an instrument's journey doesn't begin and end in the surgeon's hands.
Every instrument moves through a continuous cycle of use, point-of-use treatment, transport, cleaning, inspection, assembly, sterilization, and reuse. Each step influences the next. The operating room and sterile processing department are not separate systems. They are interconnected components of one surgical ecosystem.
That ecosystem is under increasing pressure. Procedures are becoming more complex, instrument sets more specialized, and hospitals face persistent challenges involving staffing, costs, and procedural throughput.
We have become remarkably sophisticated at improving what happens during surgery. But have we given equal attention to the systems that make surgery possible?
Point-of-Use Treatment Is Not a New Idea
The Association of periOperative Registered Nurses (AORN) has long emphasized the importance of point-of-use treatment of surgical instruments. Its guidance addresses removing gross soil during procedures, preventing blood and organic material from drying on instruments, and preparing instruments appropriately for transport to sterile processing.
The science is straightforward. Blood, tissue, fat, and other organic materials can interfere with subsequent cleaning and sterilization. Once biological material dries and adheres to instrument surfaces, it can become considerably more difficult to remove. Earlier treatment can support more effective downstream cleaning.
But there is a practical problem.
Throughout a complex orthopedic procedure, instruments are repeatedly exposed to blood, bone, marrow, and soft tissue. Some are used continuously. Others are used briefly and remain on the surgical field for hours.
Meanwhile, our nurses and surgical technologists are maintaining the sterile field, anticipating surgical needs, managing instruments, coordinating equipment, and attending to countless details essential to patient safety. We ask them to perform point-of-use treatment while simultaneously managing all these responsibilities.
In medicine, we have a tendency to respond to opportunities for improvement by introducing another policy, another checklist, or another responsibility. Individually, each may make sense. Collectively, they can become an enormous burden.
The answer cannot always be to ask people to do more. Sometimes the answer must be to redesign the work itself.
What If Technology Made Doing the Right Thing Easier?
Consider how much innovation we have directed toward the instruments in a surgeon's hands. Robotics, navigation, advanced imaging, and computer-assisted precision have transformed what we can accomplish during surgery.
Yet technology-assisted automation of point-of-use instrument treatment has received comparatively little attention. What if we applied the same engineering principles to the care of surgical instruments during surgery?
Imagine technologies designed to help remove organic material, reduce microbial bioburden, and support established point-of-use treatment practices with minimal interruption to surgical workflow.
There are important distinctions here. Cleaning removes organic material and other contaminants. Microbial bioburden reduction decreases the number of viable microorganisms present. Neither is synonymous with sterilization.
Intraoperative point-of-use treatment does not replace validated cleaning, inspection, and sterilization in the sterile processing department. Nor should microbial reduction alone be assumed to demonstrate lower surgical site infection rates.
The objective is not to bypass established standards. It is to make those standards easier to support.
And that brings me to what I believe is the more important opportunity.
We should not be asking our operating room personnel to perform more point-of-use treatment simply because we recognize its importance. We should be developing technologies that reduce the work required to accomplish it.
The goal should be less manual intervention, fewer interruptions, greater consistency, and less dependence on already limited human attention. Technology should not introduce another task into the operating room. It should reduce the burden of performing tasks that are already necessary.
Innovation should make doing the right thing easier, not make doing it someone else's additional responsibility.
The Hidden Economics of Instrument Cleaning
There is another dimension to this discussion that deserves greater attention: the economics.
Consider a complex revision arthroplasty requiring multiple instrument trays, extraction devices, reamers, and reconstruction systems. Every instrument eventually returns to sterile processing, where it must be appropriately cleaned, inspected, and prepared for reuse.
Instruments arriving with substantial residual organic material may require additional brushing, flushing, manual attention, or repeated cleaning. Every additional step consumes time, labor, and resources.
Now imagine if those instruments consistently arrived with less residual organic material. Could we reduce manual cleaning time, decrease repeated cleaning, and improve the predictability of instrument turnaround? Could better point-of-use treatment increase processing capacity without requiring a proportional increase in personnel or equipment?
These are measurable questions, not established outcomes of any particular technology.
The potential implications extend beyond labor costs. Instrument availability, processing delays, overtime, inventory utilization, and procedural efficiency are all interconnected. For rural hospitals and ambulatory surgery centers operating with limited resources, even modest improvements could matter.
Of course, faster instrument processing only increases surgical throughput when instrument availability is the limiting factor. That distinction matters because we need to measure what actually improves, rather than assume that an improvement in one part of the system translates into better performance everywhere else.
Innovation Begins When We Look Beyond Our Own Expertise
My experience in sterile processing changed how I thought about surgical innovation. I had spent much of my career trying to improve what happened inside the operating room, yet some of the most interesting opportunities existed just beyond its doors.
That experience eventually led my colleagues Leigh Bierdeman-Moss, RN, Chris Wylie, ST, and me to co-found SteriBasin, exploring whether technology-assisted intraoperative cleaning and microbial bioburden management could complement existing sterile processing practices.
But the larger lesson extends well beyond any particular technology.
Innovation often begins when we examine familiar problems from unfamiliar perspectives. When surgeons listen to sterile processing professionals, when nurses and surgical technologists help engineers understand the realities of operating room workflow, and when microbiologists, infection prevention specialists, and hospital administrators examine the entire surgical process rather than isolated components.
We discover opportunities that none of us might recognize working independently.
Perhaps most importantly, we begin to understand that improving healthcare does not always mean asking healthcare professionals to do more. Sometimes it means giving them better systems so they can accomplish essential work more efficiently, consistently, and with less effort.
A Different Way of Thinking
I entered sterile processing because I wanted to understand a part of surgery I had spent decades overlooking. I left with a different perspective on the systems that make modern surgery possible.
We have become extraordinarily good at developing technologies that help surgeons perform increasingly complex procedures. Perhaps we should devote equal attention to the people and processes behind the scenes that make those procedures possible.
The next meaningful innovation in surgical instrument management may not come from another policy, another checklist, or another responsibility. It may come from developing technologies that make existing best practices easier to accomplish.
Not by asking our surgical teams to do more, but by designing systems that reduce their workload while improving the consistency and effectiveness of what they already do.
Which leaves me with a question.
What if the next major improvement in surgical instrument reprocessing isn't asking our teams to work harder, but giving them technology that allows the entire system to work smarter?
Reference: Association of periOperative Registered Nurses (AORN), Guideline for Cleaning and Care of Surgical Instruments, Guidelines for Perioperative Practice.
Dr. Michael M. Karch is a board-certified orthopedic surgeon, innovator, and author focused on the ethical integration of artificial intelligence in healthcare. He is co-founder of the Mammoth Orthopedic Institute and Research Foundation in Mammoth Lakes, California, and serves as Adjunct Associate Professor of Orthopedic Surgery at Georgetown University and the University of Nevada School of Medicine. Dr. Karch holds multiple medical technology patents and co-founded Steribasin and Brava Health technologies. He is the author of The Paradox of Progress: The Roses and Thorns of Artificial Intelligence, exploring ethics at the intersection of medicine, technology, and society. His work examines responsible AI deployment in surgery, disaster medicine, and global healthcare systems
Sign up for our Newsletter!
Receive the latest articles directly in your inbox




Discussion
Join the conversation! Login if you already have an account, or create an account. We would love to hear your perspective.
Comments
0Loading comments…