GrandRoundsMD Logo
The Instruments Were Sterile When We Started.  What Happens Next?

The Instruments Were Sterile When We Started. What Happens Next?

By Michael M Karch, MD

Orthopedic Surgery • Attending Physician • United States of America

Published on 11/14/2026

We verify sterility before surgery. But what happens to our instruments during the hours that follow?

I begin every operation the same way.

Before the first incision, I conduct our surgical timeout, speaking aloud to the team gathered around the operating table.

Patient identity confirmed. Correct surgical site confirmed. ASA classification reviewed. Antibiotics administered. Allergies checked. Medications available. Temperature and humidity checked. Code status confirmed. Fire risk assessed. Sterilization indicators verified. Instruments and back table checked.

Each confirmation is answered by a member of my team.

Check. Check. Check.

It is a ritual built on decades of surgical experience, scientific evidence, and an extraordinary amount of trust.

I trust my scrub technician. I trust my circulating nurse. I trust the sterile processing department. I trust the processes that brought every instrument into my operating room.

That trust is well earned.

But there is something interesting about our surgical timeout.

It is a snapshot.

At a particular moment, we verify that the conditions necessary to begin an operation have been established. We confirm the patient, the procedure, the environment, and the instruments. We establish a shared understanding that we are ready to proceed.

Yet the operation that follows is anything but static.

Air circulates. Personnel move. Instruments are handled, exchanged, and returned to the back table. Fluids accumulate. Tissue is exposed. The surgical environment changes minute by minute.

Even during a routine operation lasting one hour, the conditions surrounding our instruments may change considerably.

This is the asymmetry that interests me.

We establish trust through a snapshot, but we practice surgery in a continuously changing environment.

Our trust remains constant.

The conditions supporting that trust may not.

What Happens After We Open the Tray?

Modern surgery has invested extraordinary resources in ensuring that instruments arrive in the operating room sterile.

We have developed sophisticated cleaning and sterilization processes, biological and chemical indicators, packaging systems, environmental controls, and rigorous protocols for maintaining the sterile field.

These advances have made increasingly complex operations possible.

But sterilization occurs before the operation. Once an instrument is exposed to the operating room environment, its microbial condition becomes subject to a different set of variables.

And research suggests those variables matter.

In a 2023 study published in The Journal of Arthroplasty, Najafi and colleagues examined microbial contamination of sterile setup tables during primary total joint arthroplasty. Microorganisms were detected in 12.5% of sampled back-table surfaces.

Similar findings have been reported in studies of surgical splash basins.

A systematic review published in the Iowa Orthopaedic Journal examined seven studies of intraoperative splash-basin contamination and reported a median contamination rate of approximately 24%, with considerable variation between studies.

A more recent prospective study involving thoracic and neurosurgical procedures identified bacterial contamination in 44% of splash basins.

These studies do not establish that contaminated back tables or splash basins cause surgical site infections. They do, however, demonstrate that microbial contamination can occur during surgery despite established sterile practices.

And that raises an important distinction.

We are not questioning whether our instruments were sterile when we opened them.

We are questioning what happens afterward.

Time Changes the Equation

Time is one of the most consequential variables in surgery.

Longer procedures are associated with increased surgical site infection risk across multiple specialties, including spine surgery and total joint arthroplasty.

A systematic review of 81 studies published in Surgical Infections found a consistent association between prolonged operative duration and increased infection risk.

Of course, surgical site infection is multifactorial. Patient comorbidities, procedural complexity, tissue injury, antibiotic administration, and numerous other variables influence outcomes.

We cannot conclude that longer operations produce more infections simply because instruments remain exposed for longer periods.

But time creates additional opportunities for microbial exposure.

Consider two instruments.

One has just been opened from a sterile tray.

The other has been sitting on the back table for an hour, exposed to the operating room environment, perhaps handled repeatedly, introduced into the operative field, rinsed, and returned.

We may regard both as part of the same sterile field.

But have they experienced the same microbial environment?

Certainly not.

Does that mean the second instrument is contaminated?

Not necessarily.

It means the original verification of sterility does not tell us everything about what has happened to that instrument since it was opened.

We routinely measure operative duration because we recognize its relationship to surgical outcomes.

Yet we have comparatively limited information about how microbial contamination of individual instruments changes during that same period.

We measure surgical time. But how often do we measure what happens to our instruments during that time?

That is a question worth investigating.

When the Operating Room Moves Beyond the Hospital

The implications become even more consequential when surgery moves beyond the controlled environment of a conventional operating room.

In civilian elective surgery, we generally rely on sophisticated sterile processing infrastructure, environmental controls, trained personnel, and readily available instrument inventories.

Military and disaster medicine challenge many of those assumptions.

Consider a forward surgical team treating casualties following an explosion.

Penetrating injuries may introduce soil, clothing fragments, environmental debris, and microorganisms deep into damaged tissue. The wounds can be complex, polymicrobial, and heavily contaminated.

At the same time, surgical resources may be severely constrained.

Instrument inventories are limited. Personnel are stretched. Sterile processing capacity may be insufficient for sustained casualty care. Water, electricity, transportation, and supply chains may be unreliable.

In these environments, the challenge is not simply establishing surgical readiness. It is maintaining that readiness under changing conditions.

The same problem can emerge in civilian hospitals following earthquakes, mass-casualty incidents, or infrastructure failures.

The operating environment changes. The available resources change. The operational tempo changes.

The need for safe surgical instruments does not.

This does not diminish the importance of validated cleaning and sterilization between patients, which remain indispensable.

Rather, it raises the possibility that technologies capable of reducing microbial contamination during an operation could provide an additional layer of support when resources are constrained.

The principle applies equally to a routine joint replacement and a forward surgical facility.

The environments may differ dramatically.

The underlying question remains the same.

From Static Verification to Dynamic Management

For more than a century, surgical innovation has focused on preventing microorganisms from entering the operative field.

Sterilization systems, antiseptic techniques, prophylactic antibiotics, and environmental controls have transformed surgical safety.

These remain the foundations of modern surgery.

But perhaps there is an opportunity to complement them with a different approach.

What if, in addition to establishing sterile conditions before surgery, we could actively reduce microbial burden on instruments during the operation?

What if that process required seconds rather than minutes and could be incorporated into existing surgical workflows without asking our operating room teams to perform additional manual tasks?

Emerging technologies are beginning to make this concept technically plausible.

The idea is not to replace sterilization or suggest that a reduction in microbial burden is equivalent to sterility.

Nor should we assume that reducing instrument contamination necessarily translates into fewer surgical site infections. That clinical relationship must be established through appropriately designed studies.

The opportunity is to investigate whether rapid, repeated microbial reduction during an operation could complement established sterile practices.

That investigation should include how contamination changes over time, how interventions perform under real operating room conditions, and whether measurable improvements in patient outcomes follow.

It is also important to distinguish repeated microbial reduction from continuous microbial monitoring. We may be able to intervene repeatedly without knowing the precise microbial condition of every instrument at every moment.

But the broader concept is compelling.

For decades, our systems have been designed to establish a safe starting condition.

Could we now begin designing systems that actively help maintain safer conditions throughout the operation?

And could we do so while reducing, rather than increasing, the workload of the people responsible for maintaining the sterile field?

That would represent a meaningful evolution in how we think about surgical safety.

Designing Systems That Continue to Earn Our Trust

After decades in the operating room, I have learned that trust is indispensable in surgery.

We depend on our colleagues, our instruments, our processes, and the infrastructure supporting them. These systems have made modern surgery extraordinarily safe, and they deserve our confidence.

But confidence should never become complacency.

The history of surgery is a history of questioning accepted practices, challenging assumptions, and discovering better ways to care for our patients. What was considered the standard of care yesterday became the foundation for the innovations of today. And what we consider exceptional today may someday be viewed as merely the starting point.

Progress demands that we continually examine not only what we do, but why we do it, and whether we can do it better.

Our surgical timeout establishes that we are ready to begin. But surgery does not stand still, and neither should our thinking about surgical safety.

An instrument that was sterile when we opened the tray deserves the same scientific attention one hour later.

We have spent generations perfecting the systems that prepare us to begin an operation. Perhaps the next frontier is developing systems that help us maintain those conditions as the operation unfolds.

Because the greatest risk to progress may not be the limitations of our current systems, but our willingness to accept those limitations without questioning them.

If we trust that our instruments are sterile when we begin, shouldn't we be equally curious about what happens to them between open and close?

Selected References

  1. Najafi F, Fernández-Rodríguez D, Parvizi J. Sterile Setup Table in the Operating Room Is Not So Sterile. Journal of Arthroplasty. 2023;38(3):562–566.e3.
  2. Rezzadeh K, et al. Clean or Dirty? A Systematic Review of Splash Basin Use and Its Infectious Potential in Orthopaedic Surgery. Iowa Orthopaedic Journal. 2022;42(2):82–89.
  3. Michalsen KS, et al. Splash Basins in the Operating Room: Clean or Contaminated? A Study on Bacterial Contamination in Splash Basins Used to Rinse Surgical Instruments During Surgery. Nursing Reports. 2024;14(4):4060–4069.
  4. Cheng H, et al. Prolonged Operative Duration Increases Risk of Surgical Site Infections: A Systematic Review. Surgical Infections. 2017;18(6):722–735.

Disclosure: Michael M. Karch, MD, is a co-founder of SteriBasin, a medical technology company developing solutions for intraoperative instrument cleaning and microbial burden reduction. The perspectives expressed reflect his clinical experience and commitment to advancing surgical safety. The technology remains investigational.

 


About the Author

Michael M Karch, MD

Michael M Karch, MD

Orthopedic Surgery • Attending Physician•United States of America

Dr. Michael M. Karch is a board-certified orthopedic surgeon, innovator, and author focused on the ethical integration of artificial intelligence in healthcare. He is co-founder of the Mammoth Orthopedic Institute and Research Foundation in Mammoth Lakes, California, and serves as Adjunct Associate Professor of Orthopedic Surgery at Georgetown University and the University of Nevada School of Medicine. Dr. Karch holds multiple medical technology patents and co-founded Steribasin and Brava Health technologies. He is the author of The Paradox of Progress: The Roses and Thorns of Artificial Intelligence, exploring ethics at the intersection of medicine, technology, and society. His work examines responsible AI deployment in surgery, disaster medicine, and global healthcare systems

Grand Rounds

Sign up for our Newsletter!

Receive the latest articles directly in your inbox

Discussion

Join the conversation! Login if you already have an account, or create an account. We would love to hear your perspective.

Comments

0

Loading comments…